Chef warns Beth and Cody that making goofy faces into a mirror will cause them to get stuck that way. It turns out he was right, just not in the way any of them ever imagined.
When Chef's mom and Leshawna's grandmother drop their loved ones off at the same time, it kicks off a dangerous competition to prove who is the most caring mother-figure.
When two new kids show up at the daycare, Duncan and Leshawna take issue with not what makes them different, but what makes them similar to the newbies.
Beth becomes the big dog on campus after she bites Duncan, but being the big dog is a dangerous thing, especially when she didn't actually bite anybody.
Cody is set to inherit a video game empire from his long lost uncle, but only if he and his friends have what it takes to conquer a fantastical live action game.
When rain derails an outside game of catch someone suggests they play it inside. This prompts Izzy to lead the group through her wildly imaginative worst-case scenario. It's an adventure so scary that the kids may never play again.
When the floor ends up covered in gum on the day of a big bubble blowing contest, someone decides that she need to betray everyone to might help herself win by helping her friends get stuck to the floor.
When all their classmates are replaced with well-behaved Australian doppelgangers in a school exchange program, Lightning and Cody start getting suspicious.
When a lack of motivation threatens to sink the kids' chances in the Sports Athletic Awards, they create the greatest mascot of all time to boost school spirit.
When Cody gets sick, the kids want to send a message back to his home planet in hopes that they can save him, but Courtney is not in favor of this plan.
Chef is devastated when he discovers his spooky Halloween pranks have never scared the kids; determined to finally get them, he agrees to hand over full control of his pranking to Gwen, whose plan turns out far spookier than Chef ever hoped.
When Izzy believes that Chef wants her to rise to the challenge of destroying the daycare with art, she gets some magic paint to bring all her creations to life.
The kids accidentally destroy Chef's decorated Christmas tree. Scared, this means they've ruined his Christmas, they go on an epic mission to replace his holiday treasures.
After failing to open a jar Chef believes he's past his prime and entering his twilight years. This prompts Beth and the kids to dig up something from his youth to rejuvenate him. That something turns out to be a ventriloquist dummy named Sue.
Chef and the kids take a field trip to Sugar's farm but ignore all of Sugar's strict and boring farm rules that have dire consequences when Chef and the kids unleash a herd of ravenous Werehogs on a full moon.
Leshawna and Izzy trick Owen into thinking he's destined to be a criminal mastermind, but when he leaves school to join the scariest gang in town, they have to mount a rescue attempt.