Vào lần sinh nhật lần thứ 16 của mình, cô phát hiện mình có phép thuật và là một phù thủy. Cô sống với hai người cô "800 tuổi" nhưng lại rất vui vẻ và không kém phần kì quặc của mình. Đó là Hilda Spellman (do Caroline Rhea thủ vai) và Zelda Spellman (do Beth Broderick đóng), cùng với chú mèo biết nói Salem Saberhagen (lồng tiếng bởi Nick Bakay) sống tại một thị trấn " Chỉ có ở phim " tại Westbridge, Massachusetts.
Morgan submits Sabrina's article to a contest and she lands a job at Scorch magazine. Zelda and Hilda move back to the Other Realm and Sabrina and friends move into their house.
First Sabrina thinks everyone considers her too young, then her babbling about herself and (oops!) magic has them thinking she's bonkers and finally an interview with Ashanti gives her some newfound respect.
Sabrina gets caught using her magic on Leonard's web-cam. While in his computer trying to destroy the evidence she gets an involuntary makeover and winds up looking like a cartoon siren.
Their house must undergo an Other Realm magical systems check without Roxie or Morgan learning about it. Finally Sabrina uses her magic on Roxie to gain her trust.
After Sabrina's room turns into a circus tent, she must walk up and down the tightrope until she finds a balance in life between boyfriend, friends and her job.
Sabrina gets tongue tied around Aaron and turns herself into a smooth talker. Her duplicate Cyrano tries to steal Aaron and Harvey confesses his love for Sabrina to Roxie and Morgan.
When Aunt Irma finds out that Sabrina is marrying a mortal she turns Aaron into a fish. The episode ends with Sabrina finding Harvey's note that says that he will always love her.