Nancy Drew, yaşadığı yer olan Horseshoe Bay'deki gizemli olayları çözmeye çalışan genç ve zeki bir dedektiftir. Nancy'nin annesinin ani ölümü, üniversite hayallerini suya düşürür. Üniversiteye yeniden başvuru yapabilmesi için öncelikle annesinin gizemli ölümünü çözmeye karar verir. Ancak kasabanın önemli isimlerinden biri öldürüldüğünde, Nancy kendini şüpheliler arasında bulur. Diğer şüpheliler arasında Nancy'nin okuldaki başdüşmanı George Fan, geçmişi gizemler içinde olan zengin kız Bess Marvin, Nancy'nin erkek arkadaşı Ned Nick Nickerson ve Ace yer alıyordur. Bu olay için beş gencin bir araya gelmesi ve isimlerini temize çıkarmaları gerekmektedir. Ancak çözmeye çalıştıkları olay onları daha da fazla gizemin içine sürükleyecektir. Tüm bu olaylar Nancy'yi dedektif Karen Hart ile çıkan babasıyla fikir ayrılığına götürür. Bu sırada doğaüstü varlıklar da Nancy'nin peşini bırakmayacaktır.
Nancy and her friends realize they need to come up with a plan to stop the Aglaeca before it's too late; Detective Tamura shows up at The Claw to bring Nancy in for questioning in a mysterious comatose girl's assault.
Nancy and the Drew Crew continue to search for clues to battle the Aglaeca. George has an unfortunate first encounter with Nick's visiting mother. Carson and Ace have a heart-to-heart.
Nancy and the Drew Crew race against the clock to find a way to destroy the Aglaeca before she can destroy them. Ace reaches out to Carson for a favor.
Tensions flare between Nancy and the Drew Crew as they continue to fight the Aglaeca. Bess makes a mistake that could cause all of them their lives. George has a beautiful bonding moment with her sisters.
Nancy and the Drew Crew learn that they have a new battle on their hands. George's strange behavior leaves Nick feeling unsettled. Carson makes Nancy an offer she can't refuse.
Nancy is approached by a group of young girls asking for help in finding a volleyball teammate they believe was kidnapped by a ghost. Meanwhile, Ace and Amanda share a moment.
Nancy and George work together to vanish the ghost who’s been timesharing George’s body since they defeated the Aglaeca. Meanwhile, no one is more surprised than Bess when a blast from her past comes knocking.
Nancy picks up a new investigating job involving the local florist and is pleasantly surprised when Gil Bobbsey is able to offer some assistance. Meanwhile, Ace receives a cryptic text message.
Gil insists on helping Nancy investigate a hunch on Moonstone Island, but Ace and Amanda are forced to step in when he is unable to be there for her. Meanwhile, Nick begins questioning Nancy's loyalty. Lastly, Odette is getting on George's last nerve.
Nancy's birthday dinner with Carson is cut short when Detective Tamura shows up with a warrant to arrest her for contempt of court. Meanwhile, George, Bess and Ace work together to summon up one of their ancestors to help locate Odette's Englishwoman lover Mary's soul amongst billions in the spirit world.
As things begin to go haywire at The Claw, a striking stranger appears looking for Nancy, and announces himself as the billionaire Tom Swift. Meanwhile, Ace has issues with the way Nancy insists on handling things with Celia.
Nancy finally has Everett exactly where she wants him. Meanwhile, Nick receives upsetting news from one of his tenants, Jake Cazine, about the youth center he wants to open. Lastly, Carson shares something disturbing with Bess.