Steve Hightower is een professionele muzikant wiens laatste grote schnabbel ergens in de jaren '70 was. De opbrengsten van zijn gages zijn aan het opdrogen. Voor Steve komt het water langzaam tot aan zijn lippen. Om niet te verdrinken, laat hij zich door zijn beste vriend, coach Cedric, overhalen om een baan als leraar op een middelbare school te accepteren. Deze school is echter niet de gemakkelijkste werkomgeving, omdat ze in één van Chicago's moeilijkste buurten ligt. Steve's leerlingen zijn dan ook een stel jongeren met slechte manieren en een onaangename instelling.
Cedric falls in love with Regina's new secretary Lovita Alizay Jenkins. As Steve's insensitivity upsets Regina, Romeo and Bullethead square off over a beautiful classmate.
For a fundraiser, Steve tries to reunite the Hi-Tops, but learns they've formed a new band without him. So he decides to make some beautiful new music with Regina. Meanwhile, Bullethead decides to quit school to work full time at his new job in the mall.
Steve blows off a banquet with the teenager he's mentoring so that he can prepare a romantic meal for Regina. Also, Romeo gets a hand from his classmates after injuring his arm in a skateboard accident.
Steve thinks his manhood is in question after Regina beats the stuffing out of a too-fresh chicken mascot at a basketball game. Also, Romeo and Bullethead enroll in a dance class.
Steve agrees to date Regina's recently dumped, vulnerable friend. Lovita helps Ced with his taxes, and discovers receipts that show he has gone out with other women. And Romeo teaches his ""Mack-a-nomics"" class to teach the guys about how to get over on women.
On their way to a conference, Steve and Regina get stuck in a snowstorm while traveling the back roads. Meanwhile, Lovita's country cousin puts the moves on Cedric.
Steve and two of his former singing partners must find a fourth voice before their group performs at an oldies show. Meanwhile, the students get a lesson in parenting.
Steve and Cedric are up for membership in a men's club, where they'll be rubbing elbows with Chicago's business elite. Romeo and Bullethead use a new camera to meet girls.
Lovita is upset when Cedric wins a pair of tickets to a Chicago Bulls playoff game and decides to take Steve. Regina is upset when a shipment of cafeteria food is not delivered.
Rumors of a big announcement from Warrington has everyone thinking he's going to propose to Regina. Romeo and Bullethead send a strict teacher anonymous love letters hoping to help their grades.