Charlie Moore (Howard Hesseman) entra alla Millard Fillmore High School di New York nei panni di supplente idealista. Dopo aver capito di avere a che fare con una classe di “fenomeni” iperintelligenti, cerca di istruirli a quella difficile lezione che è la vita. I
Charlie encourages the class to revitalize the school's literary journal, and the class votes Simone as editor-in-chief. Unfortunately, the power this position gives Simone slightly goes to her head. Meanwhile, Eric fabricates a memoir for the journal, which dishonestly wins him more attention from Simone.
The IHP are concerned when they learn a transfer student might join their class, making it necessary for one of them to leave. They fight over who it should be.