Detektiv Džejk Perlata (Andy Samberg) je dovoljno dobar policajac da ne mora puno da radi ili da se striktno pridržava pravila. Možda je to zato što ima najviše hapšenja nego ostali ili zato što su mu svi stalno ugađali. Ali, sve se to mjenja kada dođe novi šef policije, kapetan Rej Holt (Andre Braugher). On će podsjetiti "najboljeg" policajca da mora da poštuje značku.
Jake and Charles investigate a case of Hitchcock and Scully's from the 1980s. Meanwhile, Amy's uniformed officers and Terry's detectives fight over limited resources.
Jake helps Amy navigate the complicated relationship she has with her brother, David. Charles introduces some drama into an undercover mission involving Terry and Holt.
A visitor from Latvia causes Charles and Jake to investigate Nikolaj's family. Holt and Amy bring in famed forensic scientist Dr. Yee to help close a case for Rosa.
Mayhem and double-crossing overtake the squad as they try to distract Terry from his lieutenant's exam by kicking off the Halloween Heist on a new day.